How to beat the VAT rate rise

How to beat the VAT rate rise

27/1/2013

The main effect of the higher VAT will be felt by  end consumers,  which means private individuals, charities, financial institutions and companies that are not in business.
The standard rate of value-added tax (VAT) in Israel is expected to go up from 16 percent to 17 % on September 1   a month later than first planned.

Businesses in Israel that are  authorized dealers  for VAT purposes will generally pass on the increase to their customers. They are allowed to do so under Section 6 of the VAT Law, which says that if VAT is imposed at a higher rate than was previously agreed for a transaction, a business may demand payment of the additional tax from the purchaser, unless agreed otherwise.

Consequently, the main effect of the higher VAT will be felt by  end consumers,   which means private individuals, charities, financial institutions and companies that are not in business. An example of a company not in business is one that invests in real estate for the long term, not as a trading activity.

Since real estate is probably the hardest hit, here are a few examples of what happens before and after the expected VAT rate change.

Real estate

When renting out real estate, the date of VAT liability is determined on a cash basis.

If rent is actually received by August 31, the old rate applies even if rent is paid in advance. If rent is received after then, the new rate applies. This applies to commercial rentals, as residential rentals remain exempt from VAT.

When selling Israeli real estate (or shares in a property company), the VAT liability arises when the real estate is placed at the disposal of the purchaser, or registration in his name, or whenever an amount is paid on account of the purchase price if earlier.

Therefore, home buyers who brought forward a payment to August may escape the VAT increase on that payment. This also applies if they took early possession before August 1. However, when selling secondhand homes, private sellers not trading in real estate are not required to charge VAT.

As for building services, the VAT liability arises upon completion of the work and placing the real estate at the disposal of the party who ordered the work, or upon making any payment on account. So anybody who paid for building services before September 1 will be entitled to pay VAT at the old rate.

As for  combination  deals (barter deals, e.g. completed units in a new building in exchange for land), according to case law, if the land owners deliver possession of the land to the builder before September 1, the old VAT rate will apply.

In practice, possession is usually only given once planning permission is obtained.

Goods and services

What about other cases not involving real estate? If goods are sold, the VAT liability arises when the goods are delivered to the purchaser.

So the old VAT rate applies if the goods are delivered before September 1. If delivery takes place in stages, the VAT liability arises when each part is sold.

In the case of consignment deals, if not more than 10% of the price is due to a supplier before an onward sale of the goods concerned, the VAT liability will generally arise upon the onward sale date.

In the case of services, the VAT liability arises when the service is rendered. If the service is rendered in parts, the VAT liability arises on each part.

If the service is continuous and indivisible, the VAT liability arises upon completion, unless payment is made on account, in which case the VAT liability will arise on the payment when it is made.

As always, consult experienced tax advisers in each country at an early stage in specific cases.

leon@hcat.co

Leon Harris is a certified public accountant and tax specialist at Harris Consulting & Tax Ltd.

December 11, 2013

Font Resize
Contrast